I submitted some work to a major U.S. publisher almost a year ago. A few months later, I received a personalized, lengthy, warm email from an editor who indicated she liked my work but that she wasn't ready to take on the project at that point. She did suggest some changes and invited me to send it back to her. I revised and re-submitted. A few months went by and I emailed her again to check the status. She replied that she hadn't yet had a chance to get to it. A few months later, I emailed again. She wrote back: "I need more time to review this submission." And it's been a while since then...How do I interpret this? Is my story just collecting dust under her desk when I could be actively sending my work elsewhere?
YES.
Or might this mean that there may be some genuine interest and that I should just be patient?
YES.
I don't know how many times I've gotten variations on this question. DO be patient. And DO keep submitting elsewhere. The changes that she asked for should be exclusive to her... for maybe six months, to be generous. Until then, keep submitting the previous draft elsewhere. After that, submit the revision (assuming you think it's stronger) elsewhere.
Editors can take a goddamn long time to just LOOK at something, at which point they may be very excited about it. An interminable wait may not mean that nothing's ever going to happen. But you should NOT be waiting for that day (if it ever comes) to KEEP SUBMITTING.
KEEP SUBMITTING.
27 comments:
Right, that makes a lot of sense. The one bit I'm not sure on. I haven't sold yet... do you think I should keep submitting?
*ducks and runs for cover*
Six months HAHAHAHAHAAAHAA
hahahaha
oh lordy.
Six WEEKS is being generous.
(Though as an agent, I'd say that six DAYS is being generous.)
The thing is though, whatever you consider generous, since you didn't set a timeline for exclusivity at the outset, you can't get mad at her for taking forever and a day. It is what it is.
But if she's this disrespectful of your time, she might be a black hole that will NEVER get back to you. At this point I personally would just back-burner it, pretend like it is a rejection, and start subbing to other people.
If she does decide to read it and love it, then awesome - and if she doesn't, well, at least you will have been doing footwork to get in somewhere else.
As EA said, we've seen variations of this question on posts before. What I find interesting and new is the part about keeping the requested revisions for that specific editor and submit the previous draft elsewhere. Thanks for the tip.
I am curious about not sending out the revised version to other editors. I understand that the original editor did some work on this, but presumably the author agreed with the suggestions and proceeded to make them his/herself. I would think the author would want to send out the best possible version; otherwise, you're burning through editors with a lesser version.
Maybe it would make sense to send out the newer version but let the first editor have first dibs should others express interest?
Word verification: bureads ... sorta like the author's ms right now.
Cheap Flights to Phnom Penh
Flights to Phnom Penh
Phom Penh Flights
I liked it so much and very interesting, too! Thanks for sharing the experience.
Wonderful post, really great tips and advice. I was interested by your comment,
Cheap Flights to Entebbe
Flights to Entebbe
Entebbe Flights
I enjoyed reading your blog and look forward to more travel, thanks
Cheap Zanzibar Holidays
Zanzibar Holidays Packages
Cheap Bali holidays
Portugal Holiday Packages
Cheap New York holidays
New York Holiday Packages
Dubai Holiday Packages
Cheap Greece holidays
Cape Town Holiday Packages
Egypt Holiday Packages
Cheap Kerala holidays
Singapore Holiday Packages
Las Vegas Holiday Packages
It is a nice post.thank you.
Great post, very informative. Interesting!
Thank you for sharing this article. I love it. Keep on writing this type of great stuff.
Thanks for providing such a great information here.
That is amazing. I absolutely love it!
interesting thoughts
what a great post! i really like it and wanted to say thanks for sharing!
Interesting post. Thanks.
It's good to see this information in your post, i was looking the same but there was not any proper resource.
Written simply and tastefully. It’s pleasant to read. Thank u.
Great post, I enjoyed ready reading it, Keep posting good stuff like this.
great) liked everything very much) keep it up and dont stop)
that is a very good and interesting post! thank you!
Blogs are so interactive where we get lots of informative on any topics...... nice job keep it up !!
It might be part of somebodies job if he or she is working for circus or some other crazy institution, maybe even government :)
great) liked everything very much) keep it up and dont stop)
Hello my friend! I want to say that this article is awesome, nice written and include almost all vital info. I would like to see more posts like this.
Great post. Thanks!
wow , what a article post, you provide an interesting and informative article, i must say there is something happen, beacause the theme you choose was so different and so well written.
That's non sense,i dont understand how you get so much patience in your self i understand now there is some thing that because of this you keep submitting your article or project what else.I wish that this time your project will be submitted.
Post a Comment